|
A free society is, in fact, not free. That is, a free society
does not come free. More intellect, more effort, more decentralized
power is required to sustain a free market order than the
concentrated power needed to uphold an authoritarian society.
In a free social order every person must work daily to think
and do right. In despotism only the rulers must. For a just
market order to flourish, every person-despite the human passions
of avarice, ambition, and lust-must summon the will to respect
the human and property rights of his neighbor. Individuals
in a free society must govern themselves so that a limited
self-government of the whole might lightly regulate the general
welfare of all.
We
learn from history and experience that people can be moved
to do the lawful thing primarily by two social mechanisms-either
a morally grounded conscience, or by the external threat of
civil and criminal penalties. If a majority is moved to do
the lawful thing only by coercion, penalties, and jail, then
who would deny that a free society must in time become an
armed camp of police, prosecutors, and prisons? As we learned
from the late, unlamented, Soviet Union, the cynical admonition,
"follow your inclinations with due regard to the policeman
around the corner" is no practical rule for a durable
free society. When moral anarchy prevails, there can never
be enough policemen! But a free society can remain free; the
creative mind of man can achieve its loftiest aims; capitalism
can be sustained in the long run, only if the vast majority
is moved by the inner dictates of a well-formed conscience.
Such a conscience, by itself, enables every person in the
community to transact business without fear of unaccountable
theft and bodily harm. The well-formed conscience is the simplest,
lowest cost, and most efficient regulator of a free social
order.
Where
is such a conscience formed? I think this is the supervening
question of a durable social policy. Conscience is primarily
formed in children by the love and fair-minded instruction
of their parents, their family, their teachers, their neighbors,
the laws of their country and the faith of their fathers and
mothers. It is the gift of love, from parents to children,
that quickens into action the law written in their own hearts.
It is the indispensable long run gyroscope of a free society.
Many
cynical contemporaries hold to the spurious idea that the
long run is a phantom, even that capitalism can be sustained
without an objective moral code forming the conscience of
every citizen. "In the long run we are all dead,"
John Maynard Keynes taught three generations of modern economists
and college graduates. This dismissal of the long run may
have come easily to Keynes. He seemed never to have been interested
in children. Concern for children brings the long run into
view, and with it the profound challenge to form and maintain
the Judeo-Christian conscience- and its dependent economic
institutions, called capitalism.
|