This Fall Joan of Arcadia has taken TV ratings and critics
by storm.
Barbara
Hall is the creator and co-executive producer of this new
CBS drama. She has a long list of producing and writing credits
for shows such as Judging Amy, Chicago Hope
and Northern Exposure.
Though
raised a strict Methodist, Hall went through a long period
when she rejected religion, though she remained a voracious
reader with a penchant for metaphysics and physics. In an
article for only connect, she describes her decision
to become a Catholic: “Then came the events of September
11th. Until then, I had been someone who could not choose
God until I understood every aspect of Him and what He was
up to. In that moment, I decided to go ahead and choose God
and worry about the details later. I was relying on a philosophy
that a devout Catholic had offered an agnostic friend of mine:
'Maybe what God is doing is none of your business.'”
Such
frank anti-subjectivism, a refreshing change from the deeply
held narcissism that grips our culture, is just one reason
Joan of Arcadia is enjoying success. The point of
each show is not about Joan (played by Amber Tamblyn). Instead,
it is about the people Joan can help if she listens to God
and to others around her. In every episode Joan must care
about someone other than herself for something good to take
place.
Another
theme of the series is that Hall, the primary writer for the
series, emphasizes reality based story lines. Joan’s
father is the Chief of Police for Arcadia, California. Her
mother works in the administrative office of Joan’s
High School. The plot lines involve both characters, not only
as Joan’s parents, but in their professional lives as
well.
Did
I mention that Joan’s older brother (played by Jason
Ritter, the real life son of the recently deceased John Ritter)
has just been paralyzed in an automobile accident? The audience
soon gets the message that there are no easy answers to life’s
problems.
Joan
receives visits from God in the guise of various people. A
sanitation worker in one scene. A small child on the swing-set
in another. It is reminiscent of Joan Osborne’s 1995
hit, What If God Was One Of Us? The song works so
well with the show’s premise that Hall asked Osborne
to re-record it for the series’ theme song.
If
you have decried the lack of TV programming reflecting positive
values—well here it is! tothesource recommends that
you fight the urge to criticize the series because it doesn’t
explicitly articulate the exact tenets of your religious beliefs.
This seems to be an impossible standard for television to
meet.
Instead,
be thankful writers and producers like Barbara Hall have a
gift for posing good questions about matters of faith in an
entertaining way.
And
tune in, Fridays at 8 p.m. on CBS.

|